McMINNVILLE, Tenn. – A teacher who served six months in prison after being accused of having a sexual relationship with a 13-year-old student was arrested again Tuesday after authorities said she violated probation terms by running a Web site [other reports say it was MySpace] that indicated contact with the victim and his family.
Pamela Rogers Turner, 28, was ordered to serve nine months on an eight-year sentence under a plea deal. She was released from jail Feb. 26 for good behavior after serving about six months.
Under terms of the deal, she was to serve seven years of probation, register as a sex offender and perform 90 hours of community service. She was also ordered not to contact the victim or his family and not to use the Internet.
Rogers was arrested in Cookeville on Tuesday as she was reporting to her probation appointment and booked at Warren County Jail in McMinnville, The Southern Standard in McMinnville reported.
Authorities said she committed seven possible probation violations for establishing a Web site with several pictures of herself. The photos were biographical, not pornographic, but several show her wearing a bikini.
A blog on the site also included what authorities said was communication between Rogers and the victim’s 17-year-old sister, including a link to the sister’s Web site.
She is also accused of issuing a cryptic message to the victim by addressing his basketball jersey number, saying he was her hero and that she would not fall in love again for three years.
“In this case we will likely ask that she go to the Department of Corrections to flatten out her sentence,” District Attorney General Dale Potter said. “This came in such a short amount of time after she was released on probation and in our opinion these were intentional violations of the terms of her release.”
Flattening her sentence would mean serving the remainder of eight years in state prison. Rogers was scheduled to appear Wednesday morning before Circuit Judge Bart Stanley, who will later decide whether Rogers committed the violations and whether she deserves more jail time.
“I would have tried for this long a sentence the first time if I had a victim I could put on the stand,” Potter said. “But the family didn’t want the victim to testify so we had to reach an agreement I didn’t necessarily like.
“When you put someone on probation, you expect them to violate it at some point. In this case, she violated it a little quicker than most people thought.”
Her attorney, Peter Strianse of Nashville, was unavailable for comment late Tuesday night.
Back story, 7/31/2005: Shortly after elementary school gym teacher/basketball coach Pamela Rogers Turner was arrested on charges that she had sexual relations with a 13-year-old male student, word got out that during spring break of 1997, she was named Ms. Monday Nitro by the WCW (World Championship Wrestling) during a broadcast from Florida.
CENTERTOWN, Tenn. – There’s a Pamela Rogers Turner – the sweet-tempered, grade-school teacher who is seen as a role model for students.
And there’s a Pamela Rogers Turner who in her college days was the glitzy Ms. Monday Nitro of World Championship Wrestling at Spring Break festivities in 1997. The immense difference in those two images of the 27-year-old married teacher and coach has left townspeople and acquaintances here confused, as recent charges thrust this tiny town and its attractive teacher into a national media storm.
Many here are having a hard time coming to grips with the knowledge that the district attorney general has filed 28 sexual misconduct charges, accusing her of having sex with a 13-year-old boy who attended her school.
It’s that contrast also that has drawn attention from a national press corps that has followed two fairly recent and similar cases of female teachers in Washington and Florida accused of having sex with minor boys.
Dale Potter, who serves as prosecutor for Warren County, said that, while some in the media seemed to be highlighting the relationship of a young boy and an attractive older woman, ”for us, a sex abuse case is a sex abuse case.”
”It’s one thing for kids to think about and fantasize about a potential Mrs. Robinson,” he said, referring to a seductive, older woman character in the movie The Graduate. ”It’s another for that Mrs. Robinson to act.”
Those acts, he said, are felonies, not fantasies.
Turner’s estranged husband, Christopher, was not available for comment. But the 31-year-old high school basketball coach has filed for divorce, citing ”inappropriate marital conduct.”
Their Christmas card from a year ago shows a smiling, embracing couple standing in front of a mural of a moonlit cruise ship.
It’s another piece of the puzzle that no longer seems to fit the image that many acquaintances saw.
They know Pamela Turner as a former high school basketball star and a young woman admired for her polite personality and charming ways.
But Potter sees a child abuser.
His office has charged Turner with 15 counts of sexual battery and 13 counts of statutory rape. She is accused of having sex with a 13-year-old boy who attended Centertown Elementary, where Turner taught physical education and coached basketball.
If convicted on all counts, Turner could face more than 100 years behind bars, although Potter said that a more likely sentence would run from one to several years.
Messages left for Turner’s lawyer were not returned immediately.
Calls to a cell phone known to be Turner’s also were not returned, but a message stated, ”Thank you so much for the support and please keep me in your prayers.”
Billy Medley has served Pam Turner plenty of meals at his family’s meat-and-three restaurant in Centertown, where the woman ate regularly with her teaching friends.
The restaurant is a few hundred yards from the gray elementary schoolhouse where the teacher worked and where her alleged victim attended school.
The boy, who is known to many in the community, is described by Medley as ”an awesome athlete, a real superstar.”
Medley had praise, too, for the teacher, who played on a state championship high school basketball team in Fentress County coached by her father, Lamar Rogers.
”It’s a shame you can’t interview her right now,” Medley said yesterday. ”She’s an awesome woman. She’s been a real role model for the children.”
Centertown is a small community tucked into a rural corner of Warren County, where people specialize in growing plants that are intended to be shipped elsewhere.
”I’ll tell you, Centertown is getting to be known for something else now,” he said.
Opinion is mixed about the serious charges facing Turner.
”I do believe it somewhat,” said resident Howard Thomas, noting the lengthy list of charges that Warren County authorities have leveled at the young teacher. ”But of course, you’re innocent until proven guilty.”
Turner frequented a tanning salon adjacent to Medley’s restaurant.
Medley said that the teacher was quite proper and modest when she arrived to take her turn on the tanning bed. He said she was an accomplished athlete herself and that the little children at the school, where his 6-year-old daughter also attends, adored the teacher.
”They would scream, ‘Mrs. Turner! Mrs. Turner!’ whenever they saw her,” Medley said.
As school was letting out yesterday, parents lined up single file in the pickup lane.
Warren County Director of Schools Jerry Hale said that he had had more calls from media than from local parents about Centertown Elementary.
The school has a full-time counselor, he said, but there were no reports of distressed children.
Outside the school yesterday afternoon, big satellite TV trucks lumbered into position for the late-afternoon newscasts.
Parent Frank Tibbetts sat in his idling car waiting for the bell to ring. He emphasized that no one knows for sure what happened except for the defendant and her alleged victim. But the gossip was thick inside the classrooms, according to what his children told him.
”If it did happen, it’s a mighty sad thing,” he said. ”You need to be able to trust your children’s teachers.”
Metro police Sgt. Mark Chesnut has spent eight years investigating sexual child abuse.
”Less than 5% of our cases are female perpetrators,” said Chesnut, who very recently transferred to another division.
Chesnut said he could not recall any cases of female teachers being accused of sexual abuse on a student in Davidson County during his time as a sex crimes investigator.
Vanderbilt University clinical psychologist Tom Catron said that the sexual abuse of a minor could have long-lasting effects on the child.
He said the depth of the devastation would depend on the trauma associated with the abuse and on the effectiveness of the treatment.
Catron said that while in some cases adult perpetrators will claim that their young victims were consensual partners, it is very difficult to see a 13-year-old as being on equal emotional footing with the older sex partner.
He said the fact that the adult charged in the Warren case was an authority figure could hurt the child’s sense of security and ”distort their sense of what sexual intimacy is. It could really scar them for life.”
Turner comes from a well-known family of educators in Fentress County. Her father is a legendary girls basketball coach at Clarkrange High School, having won seven state championships in 29 years. Her mother is an elementary school teacher.
Turner started at power forward on the 1995 state championship team.
Fentress County Circuit Court Clerk Frank Smith said news of her arrest had been swirling around Jamestown and that people didn’t believe it. Smith, an avid booster of the Clarkrange basketball team, said he had known her since she was a little girl.
Smith followed her career in college, too, and said she played one year at Tennessee Tech before transferring to Cumberland University.
He said many people in town believed the accusations were mixed up with a nasty divorce filed in January.
”She was a super ball player and a super person,” Smith said. ”She’s one of the warmest people and nicest people you’d ever meet.”
Former state legislator Tommy Burnett, who splits time between Nashville and his home in Fentress County, said his daughter was friends with Turner growing up. Burnett said she would come around his family’s home.
”I never saw anything out of her that would give rise to my belief she would be guilty,” Burnett said. ”She’s got a super, outgoing personality.”
The Rogers family also has a history with chicken farming – one of Fentress County’s main industries.
Attorney Skid Garrett said his son was good friends with Turner’s only brother. They played football together in high school and his son would spend time at the Rogers home.
”It’s going to be devastating to this community if Pamela is found guilty,” he said. ”Frankly, everybody just loves her here.”