Porn News

Mo. Supreme Court strikes down strip-club law

JEFFERSON CITY, Mo. – The Missouri Supreme Court struck down a state law yesterday barring nude dancing and touching between strippers and customers.

The Supreme Court upheld a lower judge’s ruling that the law was unconstitutional because the bill changed too much from its original purpose as it moved through the Legislature.

The measure passed in 2005 as part of a broad bill that started out dealing with “intoxication-related traffic offenses,” but in its final version the title was changed to “relating to crime.”

“The three provisions regulating adult entertainment that were added to the fourth version of the bill during the next-to-last day of the session were not remotely within the original purpose of the bill, but rather constitute a textbook example of the legislative logrolling that [the constitutional provision] is intended to prevent,” the high court said in a unanimous opinion written by Supreme Court Judge Ronnie White.

The law banned full nudity, required dancers to stay at least 10 feet from customers and behind a rail, barred dancers from touching customers, and required all dancers and customers to be at least 21 years old.

The law had never taken effect, because Cole County Circuit Judge Richard Callahan ruled against it just a couple days before it was to kick in on Aug. 28, 2005.

The law stated that the intent was to reduce the negative effects of adult businesses, such as crime and dropping property values, and attorneys defending the law said courts had allowed restrictions on adult entertainment to serve a government interest.

Because it determined the bill had an unconstitutional change of purpose, the court said it did not need to address the broader policy question of whether the restrictions infringe on free-speech rights.

The sponsor of the law, Sen. Matt Bartle, R-Lee’s Summit, did not return a call seeking comment yesterday afternoon. But he could propose new legislation that focuses on the strip-club restrictions, opening the potential for another court battle over First Amendment rights.

A few months ago, a federal appeals court threw out another Bartle effort that banned sexually suggestive billboards along Missouri highways as an unconstitutional regulation of commercial speech. Bartle already has proposed legislation to try again on that front during next year’s legislative session.

An attorney for the Missouri Association of Club Executives, the adult entertainment industry group that challenged the law, said he expected this battle wasn’t over either.

“I don’t think there’s any doubt that Senator Bartle will try to introduce new legislation that will try to push forward his personal thoughts on what morality ought to be,” Kansas City attorney Richard Bryant said.

The attorney general’s office, which defended the law, noted the ruling didn’t address the heart of the matter.

“Today’s ruling dealt with procedural rather than substantive issues. The General Assembly will have the opportunity to fix this,” the attorney general’s spokesman, John Fougere, said.

The case is Missouri Association of Club Executives Inc. vs. State of Missouri, No. SC87154.
 

513 Views

Related Posts

Creepy Paul Mulholland, Fake Journalist, Stalker

Paul Mulholland presents himself as a savior of vulnerable women, a self-proclaimed advocate exposing the “dark underbelly” of the adult industry.

Little Puck Guests on ‘PVD Horror’ Podcast

Little Puck is the latest guest on the "PVD Horror" podcast, hosted by Dave Lizotte.

Sophia Locke Stars in Latest Evolved Fights Scene

Sophia Locke stars alongside Will Pounder in the latest scene from Evolved Fights.

Cherry Kiss Talks Perfectionism, Pressure and Loving the Grind

Cherry Kiss was en route to Exxxotica New Jersey when she learned she had received her green card. Fittingly, she had just landed at an airport in New York — home to Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty. After…

Ale Diorio Leads VoyR’s Comedy Feature ‘BootyCamp’

Ale Diorio stars in the new comedy feature from VoyR, titled “BootyCamp.”

Sir Peter, Paul Wagner Front 3rd Installment of ‘Bred & Breakfast: The Push It Inn’ From Falcon

2025 Euro XMAs Gay Performer of the Year Sir Peter and Paul Wagner star in the third installment of Falcon Studios' latest title, “Bred & Breakfast: The Push It Inn.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *