Porn News

Judge: IP addresses simply don’t identify the people behind the computers.

Check out Shai West the Video Babe of the Day at www.adultcybermart.com/VideoDay.html

from www.arstechnica.com – Several recent government raids on computer users suspected of sharing child porn online hit the wrong targets. Instead of getting the perpetrators, some of the raids nabbed a neighbor with an open WiFi network instead. One obvious takeaway: letting total strangers use your Internet connection for any purpose comes with some risk. But there’s another lesson: IP addresses simply don’t identify the people behind the computers.

One federal judge in Illinois has already taken the lesson to heart and applied it to the P2P file-sharing case before him. John Steele [pictured], the main lawyer in Illinois who has brought such cases, recently came up before judge Harold Baker and tried his standard tactic: requesting expedited discovery so that he could turn his list of allegedly infringing IP addresses into names. (Steele has also attempted to lodge the case as a “reverse class action” in which unknown copyright infringers of a pornographic film are named as a “class” to avoid problems of jurisdiction.)

Judge Baker was having none of it, rejecting Steele’s request on two occasions. Steele then sought leave to take the matter to an appeals court; Baker last week rebuffed him once more (PDF), saying it was totally improper to do expedited discovery against anonymous individuals with no representation of their own before the court.

“Could expedited discovery be used to wrest quick settlement, even from people who have done nothing wrong?” asked Baker. “The embarrassment of public exposure might be too great, the legal system too daunting and expensive, for some to ask whether [plaintiff porn company] VPR has competent evidence to prove its case.”

Baker then went on to cite a recent mistaken child porn raid, where an IP address was turned into a name—but the named person hadn’t committed the crime. “The list of IP addresses attached to VPR’s complaint suggests, in at least some instances, a similar disconnect between IP subscriber and copyright infringer… The infringer might be the subscriber, someone in the subscriber’s household, a visitor with her laptop, a neighbor, or someone parked on the street at any given moment.”

Steele’s request was denied until he can name at least one specific person in the case over whom the court has personal jurisdiction—though it’s not clear he can do this at all without going to the ISPs for help. But the judge doesn’t care about Steele’s problems.

“The imprimatur of this court will not be used to advance a ‘fishing expedition by means of a perversion of the purpose and intent’ of class actions,” Judge Baker concluded.

191 Views

Related Posts

Splatbukkake Streets ‘The Corruption of Sunflower Doll’

U.K.-based adult production company British Bukkake Productions has released a new edition of its Splatbukkake showcase series "The Corruption of...," this entry featuring British starlet Sunflower Doll.

Cruel Reell to Appear at Venus Berlin

Oct 16, 2024 5:47 PM PDTHOLLYWOOD, Calif. — Cruel Reell will be in attendance at Venus Berlin, Oct. 24-27. She will have her own booth in the main hall, number 20/344, where she will sell merch, perform and interact with…

Victoria Peaks Drops New Clip

Oct 15, 2024 6:20 PM PDTLAS VEGAS — Victoria Peaks has released a new clip, titled "Nurse Victoria and Her Sub." In the clip, Peaks role-plays as a nurse, while Jack Lava serves as "the recipient of the best bedside…

EPA United Taps Cherie DeVille for Voting Awareness Campaign

Adult industry voter advocacy organization Erotic Professionals & Allies United (EPA United) has partnered with adult star and industry advocate Cherie DeVille to release a series of social media videos aimed at encouraging voting in the upcoming election.

CAM4 Names Andra Chirnogeanu Director of Business Development

TORONTO — CAM4 has appointed industry veteran and XBIZ Exec Award winner Andra Chirnogeanu as its new director of business development. Chirnogeanu joins the company after two years at Stripchat as head of business communication and with over a decade…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.