Porn News

Scalia: Court Sucks on Obscenity Definition

NEW YORK — The government can decide what artwork is worthwhile without being accused of censorship as long as it is funding that art, Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia told an audience Thursday at the Juilliard School.

“The First Amendment has not repealed the ancient rule of life, that he who pays the piper calls the tune,” Scalia said. The justice, who limited his discussion to art issues, said he wasn’t suggesting that government stop funding the arts, but that if it does fund artwork, it is entitled to have a say in the content, just like when it runs a school system.

The high court and Scalia have weighed in on the issue before.

In the late 1980s, the National Endowment for the Arts sparked a public and political uproar when it helped fund exhibits of photographer Robert Mapplethorpe’s homoerotic images and a photograph by Andres Serrano of a crucifix immersed in urine.

Critics contended the NEA was financing obscenity, and Congress passed an arts-funding law in 1990 requiring public values be considered when handing out grants.

The Supreme Court upheld that law in 1998, ruling that the government need not subsidize art it considers indecent. Justice David H. Souter was the only dissenter, saying the law was overbroad and had “a significant power to chill artistic production and display.”

Scalia said Thursday he believes the government did not violate the First Amendment in the case of the Serrano photo _ it did not pass any law to throw the “modern day DaVinci” into jail nor did it stop him from displaying his art, he said.

“I can truly understand the discomfort with government making artistic choices, but the only remedy is to get government out of funding,” he told the audience.

Scalia said the Supreme Court has not done a very good job of framing a definition of obscenity, which the First Amendment does not protect.

“The line between protected pornography and unprotected obscenity lies between appealing to a good healthy interest in sex and appealing to a depraved interest, whatever that means,” Scalia said in stating the court’s position.

The result is that every small town in America must tolerate the existence of a porn shop, he said.

175 Views

Related Posts

Brad Bronton to Appear at X3

Dec 25, 2024 3:00 PM PSTLOS ANGELES — Brad Bronton will appear at the X3 Expo in January. “Super excited to be a part of the upcoming expo,” said Bronton. “A bit of a country mouse cammer heading to the…

AVN Opens Talent RSVPs for 2025 Awards Show

AVN Media Network formally invites 2025 AVN Awards nominees and other adult industry talent to submit their requests through the now-active Talent RSVP Site for passes to the 42nd annual AVN Awards Show, presented by MyFreeCams.

Daisy Diva Stars in Latest From TheFlourishXXX

Dec 24, 2024 4:22 PM PSTLOS ANGELES — Daisy Diva stars alongside Ace Bigs in the new scene from TheFlourishXXX, titled "Daisy Tricks Ace to Come in Looking for His Friend." According to a rep, the scene finds Ace Bigs…

Aubrey Kate Receives XMA Nod

Dec 23, 2024 4:07 PM PSTLOS ANGELES — Aubrey Kate has received a nomination for Fav Trans Creator at the 2025 XMA Awards. “It’s been an amazing year, packed with accomplishment and new ventures,” said Kate. “Winning the XBIZ Fan…

Brazzers Announces ‘Wet Hot Indian Wedding’ Limited Series

Brazzers on Monday announced the release of Wet Hot Indian Wedding, a four-part series starring Aaliyah Yasin, Suraya Ndia, Candy Scott, Bilbo Shaggins, Danny D and Xander Corvus.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.